- Home
- Search
- Gary A Williams
- PHYSICS 1A
AD
Based on 46 Users
TOP TAGS
- Tough Tests
Grade distributions are collected using data from the UCLA Registrar’s Office.
Grade distributions are collected using data from the UCLA Registrar’s Office.
Grade distributions are collected using data from the UCLA Registrar’s Office.
Sorry, no enrollment data is available.
AD
What truly encapsulates what the professor's mindset on how he organizes his course is this one phrase he said after seeing the midterm scores on our midterm. A whopping 64% was the average. Clearly, the majority of this class was struggling with the content and the test was very VERY difficult. Despite this he looks at the 14 people (out of the hundreds of students who took this class) who received a 100% and says: "I need to make the final harder." He looks at the minority succeeding outliers and uses those as a baseline for the difficultly of his tests, which are very VERY difficult.
The lectures are also very unengaging. It is almost impossible to stay completely focused throughout the two hour lectures. He sometimes sounds as though he is not interested in the content he is teaching either. The lecture content itself seems very trivial in comparison to the textbook which basically teaches the exact same thing, but at least you can go at your own pace.
The difficulty spikes between the things you are required to do are nothing short of phenomenal. The homework are not too bad, fairly standard. Maybe have to search up a problem or two. Maybe slightly above average of a professor's homework expectations. The quizzes and tests are dreadful to say the least. Let me walk you through the standard physic's students process in taking these tests. Glance at the question, see some horrific contraption that you have NEVER seen in any form on the homework, lecture, or practice problems you might have looked up. On the first quiz you think "oh it might not be that bad! the given values are only equal to 1, 2, or 0.5. this can be doable." Then, you find that you are crafting these convoluted statements in order to write what hardly resembles a solid answer. You turn it in and the only relief you have is that the pain is over. Only to have quite an aftershock as you receive your grade back.
This class was hell. And if you were present for the very chaotic 2022 winter quarter where all hell broke loose, then you'll know just how bad it was. Avoid this class as much as you can. If you are unfortunate enough to take it, brace yourself.
My guy Williams is a physics legend as a researcher, but definitely not the best prof out there. His hw is pretty easy, which is just mastering physics assignments, however, beware of his midterms and finals: I scrapped an A- only cause I had a lot of previous knowledge. Do a lot of practice problems if u can and pray to your textbook. His lectures are basically useless and try to avoid him if it is your first time to take physics.
This class was pretty difficult, not gonna lie. The average on the first midterm was 56%, and on the second it was 46%. The final average was 59%. The curve was nice though, so I got an A- after scoring between a half and a whole standard deviation above the mean on each exam.
The grades were 10% homework, 22.5% for each midterm, and 45% final. The homework wasn't too bad, as it was one problem set per week that took about two hours on average. I've already touched on the tough exams. Partial credit is awarded, but one mistake can still tank your score because each midterm is only 3 questions (the final was 6).
His lectures were pretty dry, and there were times where he seemed somewhat condescending, such as when he said "it didn't seem that hard to me" or something along those lines about the second midterm. If you can, I would recommend looking elsewhere.
Williams is a professor who cares about his students. Don't get me wrong, but he is a pretty nice lecturer. Although he spends time deriving equations (which we don't really need to know), he still explains the concepts fairly well. But then again, I had three years of physics experience prior to taking his class, so I must warn you, if you have NO prior experience in physics, try to look for a better professor, although it would be kinda hard since Williams is pretty good.
In Williams' class, you will get a homework set every week. Some of the problems may seem hard, but after Williams lectures through the material and you have your Friday discussion, it really isn't that bad.
The midterms aren't that bad. But the final is pretty hard.
All in all, if you read the chapters in the physics book, go to every lecture, do all of your homework, you should be fine for the tests (especially when they give out partial credit they're pretty generous I must say).
Ok the other people that posted reviews for Fall 2019 were mostly just salty about the second midterm being a little more challenging. I got a 4 on AP Physics 1 and got a 99 on the first midterm, 67 on the second, and haven't gotten my final grade back yet but it was about the same difficulty. Midterms are three questions that feel like more in-depth AP Physics questions (gives you a situation, asks you to find various things about it), and you have 50 minutes to complete it. Final was 6 problems and you had 3 hours, making it much less stressful.
Homework is done online on mastering physics, which also has the textbook, but I never really looked at that at all. Your homework is graded as you work on it (5 tries per problem), and most of the problems can be googled somewhere if you get stuck, just make sure you understand it in the end.
The lectures themselves are stereotypical physics lectures, professor writing on the board, doing demos with ramps and blocks, etc, so kinda slow for an 8am but manageable. They're also all on Bruinwalk but the camera work is questionable sometimes. Also the math 32A corequisite is barely even required, most of the integrating and differentiating is for deriving new equations, I don't think it was on a test at all.
All in all I'd probably take another class with Professor Williams if I had the chance to. Also take those other reviews with a grain of salt since they were made right after a midterm, if you understood AP Physics 1 you should be fine.
By far the worst prfessor I've had at UCLA. Whoever mentioned earlier that his classes teach grade-school level physics and expect PhD level exam answears hit the nail on the head. I wish I had listened to the advice on this page.
DO NOT TAKE!!!
All 5 quizzes and the midterm were very easy. The final (3 hrs) was extremely hard.
I attended every single lecture, took good notes, did all homework, and scored almost 100% on all quizzes and the midterm, but I only got a 90% on the final.
The most helpful things that he taught were the step-by-step manner to solve problems, some general techniques, and some common derivations that you need for almost every single problem (e.g. constructing a coordinate system and deriving relations between the accelerations of different objects).
Avoid him if you can because it's too difficult, and if you can't, make sure you know from inside out those problem-solving techniques.
I would recommend taking this class with another professor. The workload is manageable although the homework can take forever if you do not study the material by yourself. The lectures are centered around multiple examples of problems that are not always helpful to understand the material. The professor uploads weekly practice problems for each chapter without ever bothering to upload the solutions to these problems. The quizzes are generally easy and the worst one is dropped. There is only one midterm which will most likely be curved. I stopped attending lectures after week 6 since they do not really help you gain a better understanding of the material that you have to know for the final. If you really like physics and want to gain a better understanding chose a different professor.
Prof Williams is the WORST instructor I’ve ever had at any institution PERIOD. His lectures are beyond disorganized and after the first midterm I simply stopped attending them. The content of the class and the questions on the exams aren't actually that hard but his shocking ineptitude to teach means I spend 20 hours a week studying the textbook and the internet in order to succeed. The curve okay but it’s far worse than Corbin and at least Corbin is a good lecturer. AVOID AT ALL COSTS (seriously, you’ll thank me later)
Overall thoughts: This was a very tough class, as Prof. Williams' midterms and finals are not easy (Midterm 1 median: 55%, Midterm 2 median: 58%, Final median: 68%). It is so easy to make careless mistakes here and there, which will mean the difference between an A and an A-, an A- and a B, and so on. If you can solve physics problems in which each part is dependent upon one or two previous calculations that you need to arrive at yourself, and you can do so without making too many mistakes, then you can get an A in this class. My estimation is that the top 15-20% of this class will receive an A, and overall, 50% of the class receives A's and B's. You'll undoubtedly need to put in many hours of studying every week to get an A.
Here's the grading breakdown: Homework - 10%, Midterms - 22.5% each, Final - 45%.
ATTENDING LECTURE: A must. There are important concepts and problems in each chapter that Williams will go over that will help you with your homework and exams.
ATTENDING DISCUSSION: Definitely not necessary. Depends on your TA, mine was pretty useless. I stopped going after two weeks.
HOMEWORK: Mastering Physics, from 10-15 problems a week. You get a few tries for each problem, and you lose some points for each incorrect answer. Completing homework is a good start to doing well on the exams. Understanding every problem in the homework is a must.
EXAMS: Understand all the homework problems, and do the additional practice that is posted on Mastering Physics. You'll eventually need to be able to solve them relatively fast in order to do well on the midterms, as only 50 minutes is allotted per midterm.
OFFICE HOURS: Professor Williams held 4 hours of OH a week this quarter, and in addition, he has answered all of the questions I have had! He understands physics - although sometimes in his answer keys for exams or in-class he makes a careless mistake here and there.
Good luck!
What truly encapsulates what the professor's mindset on how he organizes his course is this one phrase he said after seeing the midterm scores on our midterm. A whopping 64% was the average. Clearly, the majority of this class was struggling with the content and the test was very VERY difficult. Despite this he looks at the 14 people (out of the hundreds of students who took this class) who received a 100% and says: "I need to make the final harder." He looks at the minority succeeding outliers and uses those as a baseline for the difficultly of his tests, which are very VERY difficult.
The lectures are also very unengaging. It is almost impossible to stay completely focused throughout the two hour lectures. He sometimes sounds as though he is not interested in the content he is teaching either. The lecture content itself seems very trivial in comparison to the textbook which basically teaches the exact same thing, but at least you can go at your own pace.
The difficulty spikes between the things you are required to do are nothing short of phenomenal. The homework are not too bad, fairly standard. Maybe have to search up a problem or two. Maybe slightly above average of a professor's homework expectations. The quizzes and tests are dreadful to say the least. Let me walk you through the standard physic's students process in taking these tests. Glance at the question, see some horrific contraption that you have NEVER seen in any form on the homework, lecture, or practice problems you might have looked up. On the first quiz you think "oh it might not be that bad! the given values are only equal to 1, 2, or 0.5. this can be doable." Then, you find that you are crafting these convoluted statements in order to write what hardly resembles a solid answer. You turn it in and the only relief you have is that the pain is over. Only to have quite an aftershock as you receive your grade back.
This class was hell. And if you were present for the very chaotic 2022 winter quarter where all hell broke loose, then you'll know just how bad it was. Avoid this class as much as you can. If you are unfortunate enough to take it, brace yourself.
My guy Williams is a physics legend as a researcher, but definitely not the best prof out there. His hw is pretty easy, which is just mastering physics assignments, however, beware of his midterms and finals: I scrapped an A- only cause I had a lot of previous knowledge. Do a lot of practice problems if u can and pray to your textbook. His lectures are basically useless and try to avoid him if it is your first time to take physics.
This class was pretty difficult, not gonna lie. The average on the first midterm was 56%, and on the second it was 46%. The final average was 59%. The curve was nice though, so I got an A- after scoring between a half and a whole standard deviation above the mean on each exam.
The grades were 10% homework, 22.5% for each midterm, and 45% final. The homework wasn't too bad, as it was one problem set per week that took about two hours on average. I've already touched on the tough exams. Partial credit is awarded, but one mistake can still tank your score because each midterm is only 3 questions (the final was 6).
His lectures were pretty dry, and there were times where he seemed somewhat condescending, such as when he said "it didn't seem that hard to me" or something along those lines about the second midterm. If you can, I would recommend looking elsewhere.
Williams is a professor who cares about his students. Don't get me wrong, but he is a pretty nice lecturer. Although he spends time deriving equations (which we don't really need to know), he still explains the concepts fairly well. But then again, I had three years of physics experience prior to taking his class, so I must warn you, if you have NO prior experience in physics, try to look for a better professor, although it would be kinda hard since Williams is pretty good.
In Williams' class, you will get a homework set every week. Some of the problems may seem hard, but after Williams lectures through the material and you have your Friday discussion, it really isn't that bad.
The midterms aren't that bad. But the final is pretty hard.
All in all, if you read the chapters in the physics book, go to every lecture, do all of your homework, you should be fine for the tests (especially when they give out partial credit they're pretty generous I must say).
Ok the other people that posted reviews for Fall 2019 were mostly just salty about the second midterm being a little more challenging. I got a 4 on AP Physics 1 and got a 99 on the first midterm, 67 on the second, and haven't gotten my final grade back yet but it was about the same difficulty. Midterms are three questions that feel like more in-depth AP Physics questions (gives you a situation, asks you to find various things about it), and you have 50 minutes to complete it. Final was 6 problems and you had 3 hours, making it much less stressful.
Homework is done online on mastering physics, which also has the textbook, but I never really looked at that at all. Your homework is graded as you work on it (5 tries per problem), and most of the problems can be googled somewhere if you get stuck, just make sure you understand it in the end.
The lectures themselves are stereotypical physics lectures, professor writing on the board, doing demos with ramps and blocks, etc, so kinda slow for an 8am but manageable. They're also all on Bruinwalk but the camera work is questionable sometimes. Also the math 32A corequisite is barely even required, most of the integrating and differentiating is for deriving new equations, I don't think it was on a test at all.
All in all I'd probably take another class with Professor Williams if I had the chance to. Also take those other reviews with a grain of salt since they were made right after a midterm, if you understood AP Physics 1 you should be fine.
By far the worst prfessor I've had at UCLA. Whoever mentioned earlier that his classes teach grade-school level physics and expect PhD level exam answears hit the nail on the head. I wish I had listened to the advice on this page.
DO NOT TAKE!!!
All 5 quizzes and the midterm were very easy. The final (3 hrs) was extremely hard.
I attended every single lecture, took good notes, did all homework, and scored almost 100% on all quizzes and the midterm, but I only got a 90% on the final.
The most helpful things that he taught were the step-by-step manner to solve problems, some general techniques, and some common derivations that you need for almost every single problem (e.g. constructing a coordinate system and deriving relations between the accelerations of different objects).
Avoid him if you can because it's too difficult, and if you can't, make sure you know from inside out those problem-solving techniques.
I would recommend taking this class with another professor. The workload is manageable although the homework can take forever if you do not study the material by yourself. The lectures are centered around multiple examples of problems that are not always helpful to understand the material. The professor uploads weekly practice problems for each chapter without ever bothering to upload the solutions to these problems. The quizzes are generally easy and the worst one is dropped. There is only one midterm which will most likely be curved. I stopped attending lectures after week 6 since they do not really help you gain a better understanding of the material that you have to know for the final. If you really like physics and want to gain a better understanding chose a different professor.
Prof Williams is the WORST instructor I’ve ever had at any institution PERIOD. His lectures are beyond disorganized and after the first midterm I simply stopped attending them. The content of the class and the questions on the exams aren't actually that hard but his shocking ineptitude to teach means I spend 20 hours a week studying the textbook and the internet in order to succeed. The curve okay but it’s far worse than Corbin and at least Corbin is a good lecturer. AVOID AT ALL COSTS (seriously, you’ll thank me later)
Overall thoughts: This was a very tough class, as Prof. Williams' midterms and finals are not easy (Midterm 1 median: 55%, Midterm 2 median: 58%, Final median: 68%). It is so easy to make careless mistakes here and there, which will mean the difference between an A and an A-, an A- and a B, and so on. If you can solve physics problems in which each part is dependent upon one or two previous calculations that you need to arrive at yourself, and you can do so without making too many mistakes, then you can get an A in this class. My estimation is that the top 15-20% of this class will receive an A, and overall, 50% of the class receives A's and B's. You'll undoubtedly need to put in many hours of studying every week to get an A.
Here's the grading breakdown: Homework - 10%, Midterms - 22.5% each, Final - 45%.
ATTENDING LECTURE: A must. There are important concepts and problems in each chapter that Williams will go over that will help you with your homework and exams.
ATTENDING DISCUSSION: Definitely not necessary. Depends on your TA, mine was pretty useless. I stopped going after two weeks.
HOMEWORK: Mastering Physics, from 10-15 problems a week. You get a few tries for each problem, and you lose some points for each incorrect answer. Completing homework is a good start to doing well on the exams. Understanding every problem in the homework is a must.
EXAMS: Understand all the homework problems, and do the additional practice that is posted on Mastering Physics. You'll eventually need to be able to solve them relatively fast in order to do well on the midterms, as only 50 minutes is allotted per midterm.
OFFICE HOURS: Professor Williams held 4 hours of OH a week this quarter, and in addition, he has answered all of the questions I have had! He understands physics - although sometimes in his answer keys for exams or in-class he makes a careless mistake here and there.
Good luck!
Based on 46 Users
TOP TAGS
- Tough Tests (20)